Current:Home > reviewsRuling blocks big changes to Utah citizen initiatives but lawmakers vow appeal -FundGuru
Ruling blocks big changes to Utah citizen initiatives but lawmakers vow appeal
View
Date:2025-04-13 01:40:15
Utah voters won’t decide this November on a proposal to amend the state constitution that would let state lawmakers rewrite voter-approved ballot measures but the question will remain on ballots with just weeks to go until the election, a judge ruled Thursday.
Legislative leaders vowed to appeal to the Utah Supreme Court.
Salt Lake County District Judge Dianna Gibson sided with the League of Women Voters and others who challenged the measure, agreeing that it carries misleading ballot language and has not been advertised in newspapers statewide as required.
To keep ballot-printing and other election deadlines on track, the amendment will still be on Utah ballots in November but won’t be counted.
The ballot language — which says the change would “strengthen the initiative process” — is not only misleading but says the opposite of what the amendment would actually do, a League of Women Voters attorney argued in a hearing Wednesday.
Gibson agreed in her ruling.
“The short summary the Legislature chose does not disclose the chief feature, which is also the most critical constitutional change — that the Legislature will have unlimited right to change laws passed by citizen initiative,” Gibson wrote.
An attorney for Utah lawmakers stood by the ballot language in the hearing. But lawmakers’ argument that extensive media coverage of the proposed amendment suffices for statewide publication also didn’t sway the judge.
“No evidence has been presented that either the Legislature or the lieutenant governor ‘has caused’ the proposed constitutional amendment to appear in any newspaper in Utah,” Gibson wrote, referring to the publication requirement in Utah law.
The amendment stems from a Utah Supreme Court ruling in July which upheld a ban on drawing district lines to protect incumbents or favor a political party. Lawmakers responded by seeking the ability to limit such voter-approved measures.
Meeting in a special session in late August, they approved the state constitutional amendment for voters to decide in November.
Opponents who sued Sept. 5 to block the proposed amendment have been up against tight deadlines, with less two months to go until the election.
In Wednesday’s hearing, Gibson asked Tyler Green, an attorney for the lawmakers being sued, whether some responsibility for the tight deadline fell to the Legislature.
“The legislature can’t move on a dime,” Green responded.
Legislative leaders in a statement criticized Gibson’s ruling as a “policy-making action from the bench.”
“It’s disheartening that the courts – not the 1.9 million Utah voters – will determine the future policies of our state. This underscores our concerns about governance by initiative,” said the statement by Senate President President J. Stuart Adams and House Speaker Mike Schultz.
The statement blamed organizers in Washington, D.C., with “seemingly unlimited funds” for the ruling and vowed to “exhaust all options” including a state supreme court appeal.
The amendment has been a “power hungry” attempt to silence voter voices, Salt Lake County Democratic Party Chairman Jade Velazquez said in a statement.
“We must be prepared for more attempts by the Republicans in our Legislature to expand their power at the expense of Utahns’ freedoms,” Velazquez said.
The proposed amendment springs from a 2018 ballot measure that created an independent commission to draw legislative districts every decade. The ballot measure has met ongoing resistance from the Republican-dominated Legislature.
In 2020, lawmakers stripped from it a ban on gerrymandering. Then, when the commission drew up a new congressional map, they ignored it and passed its own.
The map split Democratic-leaning Salt Lake City into four districts, each of which is now represented by a Republican.
veryGood! (9232)
Related
- Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
- Justin Timberlake Arrested for DWI in New York
- Secret Service agent robbed at gunpoint during Biden’s Los Angeles trip, police say
- Celine Dion tearfully debuts new doc amid health battle: 'Hope to see you all again soon'
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- China blames Philippines for ship collision in South China Sea. Manila calls the report deceptive
- The beginners guide to celebrating Juneteenth
- Judge orders BNSF to pay Washington tribe nearly $400 million for trespassing with oil trains
- Former Syrian official arrested in California who oversaw prison charged with torture
- NFL training camp dates 2024: When all 32 teams start their schedule
Ranking
- Sarah J. Maas books explained: How to read 'ACOTAR,' 'Throne of Glass' in order.
- Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp meets South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol during overseas trip
- Columbus Blue Jackets fire coach Pascal Vincent after one season
- Glow Up Your Pride Month Look with These Limited Edition Beauty & Makeup Sets
- See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
- U.S.-born kitefoiler J.J. Rice dies at age 18 in diving accident weeks before his Olympics debut
- Israeli military says it will begin a daily tactical pause to allow for humanitarian aid into southern Gaza
- Montana canal siphon splits open, flooding area and threatening local farming industry
Recommendation
Krispy Kreme offers a free dozen Grinch green doughnuts: When to get the deal
American tourist found dead on Greek island Mathraki, 3 other tourists missing
Brooklyn pastor 'Bling Bishop' sentenced to 9 years in prison for fraud, extortion
McDonald's ends AI drive-thru orders — for now
The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
What College World Series games are on Tuesday? Two teams will be eliminated
USA Swimming named in explosive sexual abuse lawsuit involving former coach Joseph Bernal
Phony lawyer gets 14 years in scheme to dupe migrants and border agents in smuggling op